The German automotive industry is currently facing an increasingly precarious situation, struggling with declining sales and soaring production costsThis detrimental combination has left major players such as the Volkswagen Group and Mercedes-Benz far behind their competitors, particularly as the transition to electric vehicles (EVs) becomes more urgentThe industry's path to adapt to this electric future is riddled with challenges, and without significant intervention, Germany risks losing thousands of manufacturing jobs to countries that are more aggressively pursuing investments for manufacturing.

As Europe's largest economy, Germany is ensnared in a web of industrial decline, a predicament exacerbated by the meteoric rise of China's advanced manufacturing capabilities, compounded by disruptions from the pandemic and interruptions in inexpensive natural gas supplies from RussiaEconomists warn that if new stimulating measures are not introduced, Germany might soon see a mass exodus of manufacturing jobs to low-cost nations eager to attract investments.

Hildegard Müller of the German Automotive Industry Association has expressed the urgent need for economic revitalization, emphasizing that the next government must focus on reducing bureaucratic hurdles and fostering economic growth to restore Germany's competitive edgeIts automotive industry, representing approximately 5% of the country's economy and employing nearly 780,000 people, faces a bleak outlook as competitive pressures from the Chinese market and reduced demand for electric vehicles in Europe weigh heavily on manufacturers' strategies.

Foreseeing tumultuous trade relations, the fact that about three-quarters of cars manufactured in Germany are exported amplifies the sensitivity of the automotive sector to rising trade barriersThe recent decision by the U.S. president to impose a 25% tariff on steel and aluminum imports has further escalated tensions that have been brewing since he took office

Advertisements

This included threats of punitive measures against Canada, Mexico, and the European Union, where many German automotive manufacturers operate significant production facilities.

Executives in the German automotive sector have vocally opposed these tariffs, including those imposed on Chinese electric vehicles by the EUOliver Zipse, CEO of BMW, recently underscored the importance of free trade, identifying it as a crucial driver of growth and progressMeanwhile, the U.S. market, with its robust demand for SUVs coupled with a gradual transition to electric vehicles, has become a significant source of revenue for German manufacturers like BMW, Porsche, and Mercedes-Benz, all benefiting from the existing sales of high-margin gas-powered cars.

Trade analysts, including BNP Paribas's Benedict Lowey, predict a backlash in Europe, portraying the ongoing negotiations between the EU and the U.S. as indicative of a protracted conflictGerman Chancellor Olaf Scholz has indicated a willingness to support a European response, with industry leaders closely watching the potential election of Christian Democratic Union candidate Friedrich Merz, who is seen as having a more conciliatory approach toward the U.S. president.

Among the pressing issues for great concern to automotive executives is the unpredictability of manufacturing costs, primarily driven by the volatile energy marketThe abrupt rise in energy prices following the war in Ukraine has maintained a stranglehold over cost structures, especially since Germany heavily relies on fossil fuels to power its electricity supply during the colder months.

With electricity prices in Germany hovering around three times higher than those in the U.S. and about 40% above French rates, the competitive disadvantage is apparentFrance's energy relies largely on stable and inexpensive nuclear energy sources, while the various political factions in Germany promise to alleviate energy costs but disagree fundamentally on the methods to achieve that.

Matthias Schmidt, an independent auto analyst based near Hamburg, points out that Germany is one of the last truly industrialized nations in Europe, relying on domestic suppliers for critical manufacturing components

Advertisements

The cost stability of energy remains vital for the automotive sector's sustainability.

Germany's heavy reliance on the Chinese market presents another issue, as it has become a primary source of revenue and profit for manufacturersHowever, increasing competition within China and waning demand for luxury goods have raised red flags for these companiesThe intense price war spurred by electric vehicle makers like Tesla and local brands like BYD has led to grave concerns over market share and profitability.

In light of the geopolitical climate and the acknowledgment of the risks associated with relying on Russian natural gas, Scholz's government is attempting to recalibrate its relationship with China, urging German companies to mitigate their operational risks in the regionMerz has echoed these warnings, highlighting the considerable risks involved in investing heavily in China.

Despite the growing unease, German automakers are doubling down on investments, seeking to maintain their foothold in this lucrative marketVolkswagen operates over thirty factories in China, aiming to boost its annual sales from 2.93 million units last year to approximately 4 million by 2030. Similarly, BMW plans to inject 20 billion yuan (about $2.7 billion) into its manufacturing base in Shenyang, expanding production for electric vehicles.

However, the transition to electric vehicles hit a significant snag when the Scholz administration unexpectedly scrapped subsidies last year, resulting in a sharp drop in sales that cost Germany its title as Europe's leading EV market, now claimed by the UKManufacturers like Volkswagen and Mercedes have since slowed their electrification strategies in response to lackluster market demand, while Porsche anticipates an €800 million loss due to its scaling back on gas-powered models this year.

Schmidt observes that Porsche's strategy shift suggests the potential for a prolonged lifespan of gas-powered vehicles in the market, with expectations that a Merz-led government would further support this perspective

Advertisements

Merz's conservatives hope to continue selling gas vehicles even after Europe's plan to ban new gasoline-powered cars by 2035, while Scholz advocates for tax incentives aimed at boosting EV salesBoth parties are aligned in their belief that manufacturers should not incur hefty fines for failing to meet stricter EU emission targets in the current year.

On another front, the role of bureaucracy has surfaced as a critical point of contention following Tesla CEO Elon Musk's controversial support for the far-right Alternative for Germany partyMusk has been a vocal critic of the bureaucratic delays affecting Tesla's factory construction near Berlin, intensifying calls from the German automotive sector to expedite approval processes, reduce unnecessary documentation, and resist additional bureaucratic barriers that may hinder economic growth.

All the principal political parties, including Scholz's Social Democratic Party and the Green Party, have committed to cutting red tapeHowever, Merz's campaign platform, while including tax reductions and eased regulations, stops short of substantially altering Germany's strict public spending constraints, known as the 'debt brake,' which many analysts argue is crucial for revitalizing the economy.

As the discussion around economic stimulus continues, Schmidt notes a lingering uncertainty regarding whether the budget can provide sufficient funding for new assistance initiativesThis uncertainty looms over the prospects of the German automotive industry, raising questions about how this pivotal sector will navigate its myriad challenges in the years to come.